When Should You Quit Your Creative Idea?
Creative pursuits often involve passionate dedication, but there comes a point when you must ask yourself: when is it appropriate to quit a creative idea? While perseverance is laudable, it’s equally important to recognize when an idea isn’t viable, and continuing to invest time and resources in it becomes counterproductive. There are factors to consider when deciding whether to persevere or pivot, common signs that signal it may be time to quit and a process of how to make a thoughtful and strategic decision about your creative endeavours.
Creativity is not always a smooth process. Creative blocks, where ideas seem to dry up, are common. Perseverance is often a vital ingredient in creative success. Many groundbreaking projects faced numerous setbacks before achieving their goals.
Creative projects are often driven by a vision or a message you want to convey. Perseverance ensures that you stay committed to realizing that vision, even when it seems challenging or distant.
Perseverance means sticking with an idea long enough to explore its full potential, even requiring numerous revisions and refinements. The challenge is to know how much you should persevere.
Failure provides valuable lessons. When a creative project doesn’t go as planned, you can analyze what went wrong, what could have been done differently, and how to avoid similar pitfalls in the future. This learning process is essential for personal and creative development. Failure can be a profound teacher. Sometimes, what seems like a failure is merely a lesson in disguise, guiding you toward a better approach.
Failure can lead you in unexpected directions. When an initial idea or approach fails, it can spark new ideas and directions you might not have considered otherwise. Failure encourages creative exploration and innovation.
Creative endeavours are often driven by passion. This emotional connection can fuel determination, enabling you to overcome obstacles. Passion is an intrinsic motivator. When you are passionate about a creative project, you’re driven by a genuine love for the work, not just external rewards or recognition. This intrinsic motivation keeps you engaged and committed over the long term.
While you may be passionate, persevere and are committed to learning from failure, there may be signs that you should consider quitting and using your creative energy elsewhere.
Reflect on your creative journey and your attachment to the idea. Consider whether your persistence is driven by a genuine belief in its potential or fear of letting go.
A lack of progress over time is a sure indicator. If you’ve tried multiple times and still can’t make your creative idea work, it may be a sign that a change of direction is needed. Little signs may be that repeated failures do not have much to offer in learning.
Google launched Google+ in 2011 as its social networking platform, aiming to compete with Facebook. However, despite its resources, Google+ struggled to gain a significant user base and engagement compared to other social media platforms. In 2019, Google announced the discontinuation of Google+ due to low usage and security concerns, demonstrating its willingness to sunset projects that aren’t succeeding.
Establish clear, measurable milestones to evaluate your idea’s progress. If it consistently falls short, it may be time to reassess.
External factors, such as shifts in the market or technology, can make an idea obsolete or unviable. This affects the original vision you had for the idea or project. It is good practice to continuously monitor whether your idea will still fulfil the dream behind it.
Apple is known for its product innovation but also for discontinuing products that have become less relevant. In 2014, Apple discontinued the iPod Classic, the original iPod model that had been iconic since its launch in 2001. Although it had a dedicated fan base, the Classic’s sales were declining, and it no longer aligned with Apple’s focus on mobile devices and digital services.
Engage with mentors, peers, or trusted individuals who can offer objective insights. They may provide valuable perspectives you haven’t considered.
Sometimes, your vision of the future changes and your ideas do not align with your new vision. Often, a change of vision will change your passion for some creative ideas, but persistence may keep you going. It is essential to continuously measure your creative projects against your purpose and vision. When it changes, you may want to leave some ideas behind.
In 2004, IBM sold its personal computer (PC) division to Lenovo, a Chinese technology company. This move surprised many at the time, as IBM had been a pioneer in the PC industry. However, IBM recognized that the PC market was becoming commoditized and less profitable. By exiting the PC market, IBM was able to focus on higher-margin businesses such as enterprise software and services, which have since become core strengths.
Some ideas become a resource drain. Continuing to invest time, money, and effort into an idea with diminishing returns can deplete your resources and hinder other creative pursuits. Always balance projects in terms of your available resources before deciding to continue.
Microsoft invested heavily in developing its Windows Phone operating system to compete with Android and iOS. While the platform had some innovative features, it struggled to attract app developers and users. After years of effort and substantial investments, Microsoft finally conceded defeat in the smartphone market and discontinued Windows Phone.
Letting go of an idea is sometimes difficult, but there is also the option of pivoting instead of quitting. Pivoting is rethinking your idea from another perspective and considering how it may be adapted for a different purpose, audience or application. Consider whether you can pivot or adapt your creative idea. Sometimes, a slight shift in direction can lead to success.
Instagram started as a location-based check-in app called Burbn. When it failed to gain traction, the team pivoted to focus on photo-sharing, leading to the platform’s massive success.
Burbn was initially created by Kevin Systrom and Mike Krieger as a location-based check-in app. Launched in 2010, it allowed users to check in at various locations, post plans, and share photos. While the app gained some traction, it faced competition from similar services like Foursquare.
Despite some success, Burbn faced challenges. Systrom and Krieger realized that while users enjoyed certain app features, such as photo-sharing, the overall user experience was cluttered and lacked focus. They decided to take a step back and reevaluate their product.
Systrom and Krieger made a pivotal decision to pivot their app. They recognized that the photo-sharing aspect of Burbn was the most popular and engaging feature. This realization led to the developing of a new, streamlined app version centred entirely around photo sharing.
In October 2010, Systrom and Krieger rebranded their app as Instagram. The name combined “instant camera” and “telegram,” emphasizing the app’s focus on sharing photos quickly and efficiently. Instagram’s core concept was simple: users could take smartphone photos and apply various filters to enhance and share them with their followers.
Instagram’s streamlined approach to photo sharing resonated with users. The app quickly gained popularity, partly due to its user-friendly design and the appeal of its photo filters. Its growth was exponential, reaching one million users within just a few months of its launch.
In April 2012, Facebook acquired Instagram for approximately $1 billion, shocking the tech world. This acquisition allowed Instagram to leverage Facebook’s resources and user base while maintaining its distinct identity and team.
Quitting or pivoting a particular idea does not mean the knowledge and skills you gained during its pursuit are lost. Instead, such knowledge can be invaluable in future endeavours.
The transformation of Odeo into Twitter is another fascinating story of entrepreneurial adaptability.
In 2005, entrepreneur Noah Glass co-founded Odeo, a podcasting platform. Odeo allowed users to create, discover, and share podcasts. At the time, podcasting was seen as a promising new medium for content delivery.
Odeo faced several challenges, including a lack of clear monetization strategies and the emergence of formidable competition, especially from Apple’s iTunes, which is rapidly becoming a dominant player in the podcasting space.
As Odeo struggled to gain traction and generate revenue, there was internal turmoil and a lack of direction within the company, resulting in a demoralized team and uncertainty about the company’s future.
During Odeo’s challenges, one of its employees, Jack Dorsey, proposed an idea that would eventually become Twitter. Dorsey envisioned a platform that allowed people to share short status updates with others. These updates would be limited to 140 characters, reflecting the constraints of SMS text messages.
Recognizing the potential of Dorsey’s idea, Noah Glass and the Odeo team decided to pivot the company. They shifted their focus away from podcasting and toward developing the new microblogging platform, which they initially called “twttr” (without the vowels). The idea behind the name was to convey the sense of “tweeting” or sending short messages.
The team worked on developing the platform, which later became known as “Twitter.” On March 21, 2006, Dorsey sent the first-ever tweet: “just setting up my twttr.” Twitter officially launched to the public on July 15, 2006.
Twitter quickly gained popularity as a unique and user-friendly way to share updates and stay connected. It evolved by adding features like hashtags and retweets and removing the 140-character limit. These changes fueled its rapid growth and made it a powerful communication and information-sharing tool.
Over the years, Twitter has profoundly impacted communication, news dissemination, and social movements. It has become a global platform millions of individuals, organizations, and celebrities use to share their thoughts and engage with audiences.
With the success of Twitter, Odeo’s original podcasting platform became increasingly obsolete. The company struggled to compete in the podcasting space and eventually dissolved.
In 2022, Elon Musk acquired Twitter and, in July 2023, rebranded it as “X”. Time will tell if the latest pivot will be successful.
It is also important to recognize that quitting one idea doesn’t equate to quitting creativity. It’s a natural part of the creative process, allowing space for new and potentially better ideas to flourish. For Odeo, leaving the podcasting platform behind made sense as Twitter sparked as the most viable creative idea.
The decision to quit a creative idea is complex and deeply personal. While perseverance is a valuable trait, it’s equally essential to recognize when an idea no longer serves its purpose or hinders your creative growth. Signs of repeated failure, changing circumstances, or resource drain should not be ignored. However, quitting should not be seen as a failure but as an opportunity to learn, pivot, and redirect your creative energy towards more promising pursuits. Remember that creativity is a dynamic process; sometimes, letting go of one idea opens the door to new, more rewarding creative horizons. So, be thoughtful, strategic, and open to change, and you’ll navigate the complex terrain of creative pursuits with wisdom and resilience.
Join us at ACRE28, Africa’s Premier Creativity and Creative Thinking Conference in 2024 at Klein Kariba, South Africa! https://acreconference.com
